TV Shows
Lanterns Finale Answers the Hal Jordan Mystery, and Critics Are Split
The Lanterns finale solves the Hal Jordan mystery with talk over spectacle, and reviews from TheWrap and IndieWire split on how well that lands.
The Lanterns finale answers the question that has hung over HBO's DC series since its premiere: who killed Hal Jordan? Episode 8 delivers a solution, but it hands it over through long conversations rather than cosmic punch-ups.
That choice has split critics. Here is what the reviews, recaps and creators say about how the first season ends, with the spoilers held back until a clearly marked point.
A Finale Heavy on Dialogue and Light on Spectacle
Anyone expecting a sky-high brawl may need to adjust. IndieWire's review notes there is no sky fight, John Stewart does not debut his Green Lantern suit, and the ring is barely used.
Showrunner Chris Mundy says that was the plan. He told IndieWire the creators wanted to land the story emotionally with Hal and John, and that a more action-oriented ending would have been a distraction. "We knew that if we landed it emotionally with them, we would have done our job," Mundy said.
Where TheWrap and IndieWire Disagree
TheWrap's review is mixed to positive. It says the finale stays too grounded and that some emotional beats should have been more devastating, yet it calls the episode "satisfying enough" in the end. The review also praises Noah's storyline and Kyle Chandler's performance.
IndieWire reads the same restraint as a deliberate focus on character rather than a shortfall. The numbers are friendly either way: ScreenRant reported on October 5, 2026 that Lanterns holds a 92% Rotten Tomatoes score, and that HBO's new series War ranks fourth on HBO Max's worldwide Top 10 TV Shows chart, below Lanterns.
Spoiler warning: Everything below spoils the Season 1 finale, including its central mystery and its ending.
The Killer Reveal and Noah's Secret
The finale reveals that Sheriff Kerry Kane killed Hal, according to SuperHeroHype and TheWrap. SuperHeroHype's recap says Kerry shot Hal after he confronted her about her son Noah being a Manhunter and urged her to flee Rushville with him. She panicked at the threat to her family and refused to leave. TheWrap describes it as Kerry killing her lover to protect Noah's secret.
Teenage Noah is part Manhunter, and the finale presents him as a second Manhunter found after years of hiding in plain sight. TVLine's recap says the reveal undercuts earlier messaging that Manhunters are programmed to destroy and cannot resist it, as with Zoe. It frames the finale as leaning into a debate over whether nurture can overcome nature.
Per SuperHeroHype, Zoe engineered Kerry's pregnancy with Noah after saving her in a 2007 encounter, so Kerry unknowingly became the mother of a second Manhunter. The recap adds that Noah earlier saved Hal's life with Manhunter regeneration technology after arsonists firebombed Hal's home, and that he later took the blame for Hal's death to shield his mother.
The same recap reports that Mundy picked Kerry as the killer early in development. It also says Damon Lindelof stated at a press conference that Hal's death was never meant as a fake-out.
TVLine says the episode opens in 2016 as the siege of Rushville ends, with Kerry finding a bloody Hal at the motel. Ten years later she is waiting with Schlitz and flowers when he is released from prison, and their romance, unpopular in town, begins soon after.
Important Note: The Zoe backstory, Noah's healing of Hal and the Nebraska ending come mainly from SuperHeroHype's recap, so treat them as that outlet's account. The dates also do not line up neatly: SuperHeroHype cites a 2007 encounter, TVLine's timeline runs through 2016 and a release ten years later, and the reports do not state when Hal died.
John Stewart Takes the Ring His Own Way
- First aired
- 16 August 2026
- Network
- HBO
- Created by
- Damon Lindelof, Chris Mundy, Tom King
- Starring
- Kyle Chandler, Aaron Pierre, Kelly Macdonald
John Stewart claims the role of Earth's new Green Lantern. SuperHeroHype says he does so as an independent operator, charging his ring from a fear-infused lantern forged by Sinestro and reciting a personalized oath that embraces fear. IndieWire's interview with the cast also covers the new oath.
Writer Tom King said John's revised oath fits the lore because his lantern is unsanctioned and fear-tinged, according to SuperHeroHype. That makes the finale's biggest superhero moment a quiet one: a man, a borrowed lantern and a rewritten promise.
Elsewhere in Rushville, Noah gives up the ring and lantern and chooses to play college football at the University of Nebraska, per SuperHeroHype. John lets Kerry go free, honoring what he believes Hal would have wanted for her.
Season 2 Status Is Not Spelled Out in the Coverage
The reports gathered for this story do not say whether a second season is confirmed. IndieWire's headline on its cast interview says the finale leaves a light on for one.
For now, John has his oath, Noah has a football field in Nebraska, and what comes next is still an open question.
About the author
Abiodun AdegbenroAbiodun Adegbenro is a content writer at Krafty Sprouts Media, which gives information about different topics. Abiodun studied Crop and Environmental Protection at the Ladoke Akintola University of Technology. When not writing, you'll find her listening to Fireboy DML's songs.
Keep reading
The Institute Season 2 Trailer Introduces Alfie Allen as Nolan ReevesThe Institute season 2 trailer gives a first look at Alfie Allen as tech billionaire Nolan Reeves, with the MGM+ premiere set for November 8.
James Gunn Defends Clayface and Says Hollywood Isn't a Public VoteJames Gunn answered the "Why Clayface?" question on Threads, arguing Hollywood isn't a public vote on IP, as DC's first horror film nears release.
Prime Video Debuts First Look Images for Bloodaxe, From the Vikings CreatorPrime Video has debuted first look images for Bloodaxe, a new eight-episode Norse saga from Vikings creator Michael Hirst and Horatio Hirst.